Irreductibles una història de la llengua i la literatura dels valencians

The reviews overwhelmingly praise the book as a monumental, essential, and groundbreaking work, often described as appearing only once or twice a generation. Readers highlight its comprehensive and rigorous analysis of Valencian language and literature, tracing its history from medieval origins to the present with a critical yet serene perspective. The author is commended for his ability to make complex historical and linguistic topics accessible, didactic, and engaging, employing a dynamic, fresh, and even sarcastic style that draws readers in like a novel. Many found it a constructive, lucid, and honest exploration that clarifies ideas, exposes historical pitfalls, denounces toxic trends, and helps readers understand their identity and current situation. It is celebrated for inspiring a renewed desire to engage with the Valencian language and for offering a much-needed re-evaluation of historical periods, providing new insights and original interpretations that go beyond mere academic repetition.

While largely positive, some reviewers noted a few minor points that could be perceived as drawbacks. One reader felt the book promised slightly more than it delivered, suggesting it sometimes read like an expanded high school curriculum or a compilation of short, informative posts. Another mentioned that the text could occasionally be dense, akin to a history manual, and that the sheer number of names and repeated ideas might make it feel repetitive or heavy at times, potentially causing readers to get lost. A specific critique was that the book could have placed more emphasis on significant 20th-century Catalan and Majorcan writers. Additionally, one review mentioned that the epilogue takes a "risky bet," and another suggested the book would benefit from an updated epilogue to address very recent sociopolitical changes, though this is a comment on timeliness rather than a flaw in the original content.

Overall, the book is considered an indispensable, necessary, and highly recommended work that serves as a vital mirror for Valencians to understand their history, identity, and the current state of their language. It is seen as a revolutionary and thought-provoking essay that aims to open deep debate, awaken consciences, and prompt action to preserve and promote the Valencian language. The book is particularly well-suited for readers interested in philology, history, Valencian identity, and culture, especially those who are already passionate about the language and its future. It is obligatory reading for Valencians, and potentially Catalans, who seek a comprehensive, engaging, and critical understanding of their linguistic and literary heritage, and who are willing to reflect on the challenges and the path forward for its continued "irreducible" survival.