It Chooses You

Reviewers often praise the book's unique and intriguing concept, which centers on the author's decision to interview people selling items in a local classifieds paper as a way to overcome writer's block. Many found the interviews themselves to be fascinating, poignant, and genuinely interesting, offering unvarnished glimpses into the lives of diverse individuals. The book is lauded for its ability to find profound meaning in ordinary lives and objects, with the author's distinctive perspective highlighted as a strength. Her evocative writing style, often infused with self-effacing humor and honest reflections on the creative process, resonated with readers. The accompanying photographs are frequently commended for their beauty, sensitivity, and empathetic portrayal of the subjects, enriching the overall experience. Ultimately, many readers found the book to be a touching and often funny exploration of human connection, inspiring introspection and leaving a lasting, indescribable feeling.

However, several reviewers expressed significant reservations, primarily concerning what they perceived as the author's self-indulgence and privileged viewpoint. Some felt the book focused too heavily on the author's own creative struggles and personal life, overshadowing the stories of the interviewees. This led to accusations of "freak show exploitation" from some, who felt the author occasionally portrayed subjects negatively or used their stories to serve her own narrative. Critics also pointed to a perceived disconnect between the author's affluent background and the working-class people she interviewed, suggesting a lack of genuine empathy or an underlying judgmental tone. A few found the interview questions to be somewhat shallow or the interspersed sections about the author's screenplay frustrations to be unengaging, leading to a feeling that the overall project lacked coherence or depth in certain parts.

Despite these contrasting views, the book is often described as a unique and thought-provoking read that can spark lively debate. It's particularly recommended for fans of Miranda July's other creative works, as it offers insight into her artistic process and complements her films. Readers interested in the challenges of creative work, the nature of procrastination, and the search for inspiration will likely find it compelling. Furthermore, those who appreciate experimental non-fiction, a blend of memoir and observational journalism, and stories that delve into human vulnerability and connection would enjoy this book. It ultimately appeals to readers open to unconventional narratives that prompt reflection on life, art, and the myriad ways people navigate their existence.