Positives Readers who enjoyed the first book found "It Starts With Us" to be a beautiful and necessary addition, providing a sense of closure to the story. Many appreciated the opportunity to see the main characters, Lily and Atlas, navigate their relationship as a united front, celebrating their love and fight for happiness. Reviewers highlighted the book's realistic portrayal of the lingering effects of past abuse, demonstrating that challenges persist even after breaking cycles, and firmly establishing the antagonist from the first book as an unredeemable figure. Atlas, in particular, was praised as a thoughtful and supportive partner, solidifying his appeal as a romantic lead.
Negatives However, a significant portion of readers felt the book was an unnecessary sequel, often described as a "cash grab" or an "extended epilogue" that lacked a compelling plot or substantial character development. Criticisms frequently pointed to the main characters' romance as bland or lacking chemistry, suggesting their connection was based more on shared trauma than genuine attraction. Reviewers also noted the inclusion of repetitive content, with scenes and narratives from the first book being reused. Specific elements like Lily's continued letters to a public figure and mentions of social media were often found to be jarring or unrealistic. Concerns were also raised about the portrayal of abuse and its aftermath, with some feeling the cycle wasn't truly broken and that the protagonist's support system was inadequately depicted.
Conclusion In conclusion, "It Starts With Us" is a book that largely serves as fan service, offering a definitive romantic resolution for readers who deeply desired a happy ending for Lily and Atlas after the emotional intensity of the first installment. It is likely to appeal most to those seeking closure for the couple's relationship and who are content with a more gentle, less conflict-driven narrative focused on healing and new beginnings. However, readers expecting a complex plot, deep character development, or a fresh exploration of the themes from the original story may find it falls short, perceiving it as an unessential addition that does not significantly advance the narrative.
