Johanna en Margaretha gravinnen van Vlaanderen en prinsessen van Constantinopel

The book is widely praised for bringing to life two significant female figures, Johanna and Margaretha, from the 13th-century history of the Low Countries, who are often overlooked in traditional historical narratives. Reviewers highlight the author's ability to vividly portray these women, particularly Margaretha, as intelligent, stubborn, and just individuals who navigated and maintained power through shrewd diplomacy in a male-dominated era. The historical period is well-described, making the narrative engaging and accessible even for readers without prior historical knowledge. Readers also appreciate the inclusion of details about other important historical figures, fascinating tidbits about superstitions and customs, and the interesting illustrations that enhance the historical immersion. Many consider it a phenomenal, captivating, and unique book, with some even comparing its quality to renowned historical works.

Despite the widespread acclaim, some critical feedback points to concerns regarding the book's historical accuracy and methodology. One reviewer questions the genre, noting that that while it leans towards non-fiction, the author frequently attributes emotions and personal experiences to historical figures without clear historical justification, leading to doubts about its historical responsibility. Specific historical inaccuracies are cited, such as a quote attributed to Bernard of Clairvaux long after his death and a romanticized account of Floris IV's demise. There is also criticism that the author is not sufficiently critical of her sources. Another minor point raised is the missed opportunity to reference a broader range of contemporary biographers or historians, which could have enriched the discussion by presenting diverse perspectives.

Overall, the book appears to be a compelling and engaging work that successfully sheds light on two important but often neglected female figures in medieval European history. While there are some concerns about historical rigor and the interpretation of sources, the majority of reviewers find it to be an impressively interesting and beautifully written account. It is highly recommended for readers who enjoy historical narratives that challenge traditional perspectives and bring overlooked figures to the forefront, especially those interested in the lives of powerful women in the 13th century. It is particularly suitable for those who appreciate an engaging storytelling style and are open to a more interpretive approach to historical events.