The book is largely praised for its engaging and entertaining quality, offering a light and quick read that many found enjoyable. Readers particularly appreciated the author's characteristic humorous narration and witty dialogues, which often elicited laughter and smiles. The interactions between the characters, especially the sweet high school romance, resonated with many, evoking a sense of nostalgia for their own teenage years. The main characters, Dira and Juna, were often highlighted for their appealing qualities, such as Dira's persistent and brave nature, and Juna's cool, intelligent, yet caring persona despite his tough exterior. Some also found the story's flow and language to be smooth, making it an easy and fun experience.
Disliked
However, the reviews also point out several significant weaknesses. A common criticism revolves around the portrayal of gang violence or "tawuran," which many found unrealistic, underdeveloped, and lacking in tension. The reasons for the brawls were often unclear or illogical, and the school's response to such activities was deemed implausible. Some readers felt that the humor was occasionally misplaced, appearing even in serious moments and undermining the narrative's potential gravity. The character development for Juna's transformation was not always convincing, and Dira, the main female lead, was sometimes perceived as overly clumsy, naive, or a stereotypical character. Additionally, several reviewers noted plot holes, inconsistencies, and the abrupt disappearance of minor characters. The ending was frequently described as rushed, anticlimactic, and ultimately unsatisfying, leaving some readers with a sense of disappointment.
In short
In conclusion, this book appears to be a mixed bag, offering a blend of lighthearted entertainment and noticeable narrative flaws. It is generally recommended for actual teenagers or readers who enjoy simple, humorous teen romance stories and are looking for a quick, undemanding read. Fans of the author's signature style, characterized by its comedic elements and focus on high school dynamics, are likely to find enjoyment here. However, those seeking a more realistic, deeply researched, or logically consistent exploration of serious themes, or a complex plot with strong character development, might find the book falls short of their expectations.