Khvab-i ashuftah-i naft; Duktur Musaddiqva nahzat-i-Iran (Majmuah-i tarikh) (Farsi) Vol 1

Readers praise the book for its comprehensive and meticulously researched account of a pivotal period in Iranian history. The author's engaging and eloquent writing style, combined with his unique first-hand insights from having lived through the era, enriches the narrative. Many reviewers highlight its value as an indispensable source for understanding the complexities of the national oil movement and the broader global political dynamics of the mid-20th century. It is highly recommended as a single, authoritative read for those seeking to delve into this historical event, offering valuable information that helps illuminate the true nature of key historical figures and events.

However, a recurring criticism among reviewers points to a perceived lack of complete neutrality on the author's part. Several readers note that despite the author's stated aim for impartiality, a clear favoritism towards Dr. Mossadegh and a critical stance towards figures such as Reza Shah, Razmara, and the Shah are evident, particularly as the narrative progresses. Critics observe that Mossadegh's missteps are often framed as mere errors or negligence, while the actions of his opponents are portrayed as more severe, such as 'treason' or 'autocracy.' Some also suggest that the book does not adequately address the controversial roles of certain figures, or that for those already deeply familiar with the historical sources, the book may offer limited new factual revelations beyond the author's personal observations.

Despite these observations regarding bias, the consensus remains that this book is a significant and valuable contribution to understanding Iranian history. It offers an in-depth exploration of Dr. Mossadegh's premiership and the critical period of oil nationalization, providing insights into the intense political struggles and international pressures of the time. This book is particularly suited for history enthusiasts, especially those interested in Iran's national movement, the complexities of the oil industry, and the interplay of domestic and international politics. Readers are encouraged to approach the text with an awareness of the author's perspective, while still appreciating the extensive research and engaging narrative that makes it an essential read for anyone seeking to comprehend this turbulent era.