Positives The book is widely praised for its fascinating exploration of the profound influence a group of Hungarian individuals had on 20th-century Western culture and science. Many readers expressed surprise and inspiration upon discovering the significant contributions of these figures, particularly in areas such as cinema, the development of modern science, photography, and literature. Reviewers appreciated the rich historical context provided, covering the "golden age" of Budapest, the impact of the World Wars, and the rise of anti-Semitism that led to their emigration. The author's writing style is frequently lauded as engaging, lively, and well-crafted, effectively weaving together multiple life stories without overwhelming the reader. For many, the book served as an eye-opening introduction to these exceptional but often overlooked personalities.
Negatives However, some readers found the book to be somewhat superficial, lacking the depth or new insights expected, especially when compared to more academic works on the same subjects. One particularly critical review alleged misrepresentation of facts and unsubstantiated attribution of intent to individuals, citing a lack of verifiable sources for certain claims. Organizational issues were also noted by a few, with some finding it challenging to keep track of the numerous individuals, particularly when names were similar, or feeling the narrative jumped between lives too frequently. Additionally, the book's title and subtitle were a point of contention for some, who felt they were misleading as the focus was less on a dramatic "escape from Hitler" and more on the subjects' subsequent lives and achievements. A minor point raised was the absence of female subjects and, for one reviewer, the lack of included photographs that were extensively described in the text.
Conclusion Despite these criticisms, the overall sentiment among reviewers is largely positive, with many still recommending the book as a valuable and interesting read. It is generally considered a strong introduction to the lives of these remarkable individuals and their era. This book would particularly appeal to readers interested in 20th-century European history, especially the periods surrounding WWI and WWII, and those curious about the cultural and scientific contributions of Hungarian émigrés. It is also well-suited for individuals looking for an engaging narrative that interweaves multiple biographies and highlights the impact of genius and resilience in challenging times.
