Kis magyar őstörténet a magyarok korai története az államalapításig

The book is highly praised as an informative, almost textbook-like summary of a very interesting and historically sensitive topic. The author's consistent emphasis on strict source criticism and scientific thinking is commended, presented in a readable overview. The essay-like core of the book is noted for thoroughly addressing all essential questions and summarizing current, legitimate viewpoints. A key strength highlighted is its focus not just on what is known, but crucially, on what cannot be known and the scant evidence underpinning various speculations. The volume is further enriched by dedicated chapters on source criticism methodology, a variety of supplementary materials including maps, chronological tables, a 40-page lexicon, and a selected collection of sources.

While overwhelmingly positive, the review notes that the chapter dedicated to the methodology of source criticism, though valuable, thematically stands out slightly from the main narrative. It is also observed that the topic itself is one of the most sensitive areas of historical science, often influenced by political sentiment, which necessitates the author's rigorous approach. The reviewer points out that the continuous need to emphasize scientific thinking is unfortunate, particularly in an era where self-proclaimed experts are prevalent online, underscoring the book's vital role in promoting academic rigor.

In summary, this book is considered a valuable and comprehensive work that expertly navigates a complex and often politicized historical subject. It is highly recommended for readers who appreciate a scholarly yet accessible approach to history, emphasizing critical analysis and distinguishing between established facts and speculation. Ideal for those interested in gaining a deep, well-researched understanding of sensitive historical topics, as well as students or general readers seeking to improve their understanding of source criticism and academic methodology.