Positives Reviewers frequently praise this book for its extensive research and detailed historical analysis, often noting its comprehensive scope that covers over two millennia of Kosovo's past up to the late 1990s. Many readers highlight the author's "detective-like efforts" to challenge and debunk prevalent historical myths, particularly those surrounding nationalist narratives from various sides. The writing style is generally commended for being clear, engaging, and well-written, making a complex subject accessible even to those new to the region. It is described as an excellent primer or introduction, providing significant insights and revealing previously unknown information about Kosovo's intricate history and demographic shifts.
Negatives However, a significant number of reviews express strong concerns about the book's objectivity, frequently labeling it as biased or one-sided, with a clear pro-Albanian or pro-Kosovar leaning. Critics suggest the author's purpose might be to justify certain claims or rewrite history, leading to accusations of omitting or downplaying Serbian historical facts, using unbalanced language, and presenting dubious claims. Some reviewers feel it reads more like a political column than a serious historical work, questioning its scientific impartiality. Other criticisms include the book's tendency to get bogged down in detailed battle descriptions, its considerable length, and the fact that its coverage stops before the critical events of 1999, leaving out the Kosovo War and its aftermath.
Conclusion Despite the strong divergence in opinions regarding its impartiality, the book is widely considered a vital read for anyone interested in the history of Kosovo or the broader Balkans. Many reviewers acknowledge its value in providing a deep understanding of the region's complexities, even while advising readers to approach it with an awareness of its perceived bias and to consult additional sources. It is highly recommended for laymen, travelers, and students seeking a comprehensive introduction to Kosovo's past and the origins of its contested status. Ultimately, the book serves as a powerful tool for deconstructing nationalist narratives and gaining detailed insights into the circumstances that shaped this beleaguered region.
