Positives Readers praise this historical novel as an immersive journey into the War of the Roses, often serving as an excellent introduction to the author's work and the genre. Many commend the author's ability to transport them to the Queen's court, bringing a tumultuous period of English history to life with vivid scenes and engaging storytelling. The narrative is noted for its good pace, keeping the story from becoming dull, and for its well-researched historical details that make the era easy to grasp. Elizabeth Woodville, the main character, is frequently lauded as a strong, multi-dimensional woman driven by both maternal instinct and ambition, offering a more sympathetic portrayal than traditional historical accounts. Additionally, some found the inclusion of a magical or 'witchcraft' element added intrigue and a unique ambiance to the historical narrative, enhancing the drama and making the story more captivating.
Negatives Conversely, other readers expressed significant reservations, citing issues with the writing style, particularly its repetitive nature and occasional anachronisms in dialogue. The characterization of Elizabeth Woodville was polarizing, with some finding her unlikable, inconsistent, or lacking depth, and her personal relationships often described as colorless. Critics also noted that the plot, while historically rich, sometimes felt like a detailed timeline rather than a deeply engaging narrative, with large time jumps that hindered character development and made the story feel rushed. The frequent repetition of character names, often identical across different families, also led to confusion. A major point of contention was the 'witchcraft' element; while some found it intriguing, others felt it was an 'easy way out' for plot points, veering too far into fantasy for a historical fiction, and ultimately undermining the genuine struggles of the historical figures. Some also found the extensive focus on political battles and machinations to be tedious, wishing for more personal drama or romance.
Conclusion Overall, the book elicits a mixed but generally appreciative response, often described as a compelling if sometimes flawed historical fiction. It is highly recommended for fans of historical fiction, particularly those interested in the tumultuous Plantagenet era and the War of the Roses, or readers seeking to explore the lives of powerful women in history. While some long-time fans of the author found it a departure from her usual style or less gripping than previous works, new readers often found it an excellent entry point. Those who enjoy political intrigue, historical detail, and don't mind a blend of factual events with speculative magical elements will likely find this book a worthwhile read, especially if they are looking for a story that offers a different perspective on commonly villainized historical figures.
