La straniera

Many reviewers praise the author's powerful, elegant, and precise writing style, noting its keen insight and unique voice. The prose is described as vivid, reflective, and capable of conveying complex emotions and ideas without being ostentatious. The book is lauded for its original structure, which often defies conventional chronology and blends autobiography, fiction, and essayistic elements, creating a "shapeshifting" narrative experience. This unconventional approach, sometimes likened to a horoscope or a topographical map, explores themes of identity, migration, and the feeling of being an outsider across different cultures and languages. Readers appreciate the profound reflections on communication, particularly through the lens of the parents' deafness, and the exploration of family dynamics, cultural roots (Italian and American), and personal growth. The narrative is often found to be surprising, touching, and capable of sparking empathy and self-reflection.

Despite the general admiration for the writing, some reviewers found certain passages to be overly ornate or self-consciously clever, leading to a sense of detachment or a "flat, unwavering pitch." A few felt the prose, while polished, could sometimes come across as artificial or too focused on crafting memorable phrases. Critiques also emerged regarding the book's fragmented structure. While intentional, for some, it resulted in a lack of narrative cohesion, making it difficult to fully immerse in the story or follow a clear thread. Certain parts, particularly later chapters, were deemed less engaging or even superfluous, with a perceived shift towards excessive self-reflection that overshadowed the family narrative. Some readers felt the book, despite its personal themes, kept them at an emotional distance, preventing deep identification with the characters or their experiences. There was also a sentiment that the autobiographical elements sometimes veered into self-indulgence or lacked the universal resonance found in similar works.

Ultimately, "Strangers I Know" is seen as a significant and ambitious work, showcasing a talented author with great potential. It is recognized for its unique exploration of being "foreign" in various senses - culturally, within one's family, and even to oneself. While the book's experimental nature and deeply personal reflections might not resonate with every reader, it undeniably offers a rich and thought-provoking experience. This book would particularly appeal to readers who appreciate autofiction, non-linear narratives, and works that blend personal history with broader cultural and philosophical observations. Those interested in themes of migration, complex family relationships, the impact of disability on identity, and the power of language would find much to engage with. It is recommended for those who seek a book that challenges conventional storytelling and encourages deep introspection rather than a straightforward plot.