Langkah merah: Gerakan PKI, 1950-1955

The book is highly praised for its meticulous exploration of the Indonesian Communist Party's (PKI) resurgence following earlier setbacks. Reviewers highlight how the work details the rise of new leadership within the party and its unexpected electoral success in the 1955 general election, where it became the fourth-largest political force. The book is commended for shedding light on the PKI's effective organizational strategies, including its ability to integrate and dominate various social movements involving women, farmers, and laborers. It is particularly valued for illuminating a significant yet often hazy period of Indonesian history, providing a clearer understanding of the party's considerable political impact.

Based on the provided feedback, there are no explicit negative criticisms regarding the book's content, writing style, or research quality. One review simply states "I don't know," offering no specific insight or critique. The other substantive review is overwhelmingly positive, focusing entirely on the book's strengths and the importance of its subject matter, rather than identifying any weaknesses or areas for improvement.

In conclusion, the book appears to be a valuable and thoroughly researched historical account, particularly beneficial for those interested in Indonesian political history and the evolution of communist movements in Southeast Asia. It is well-suited for readers seeking a comprehensive and detailed analysis of the PKI's strategic revival and its influence on the political landscape of Indonesia during the mid-20th century. This work would appeal to historians, political scientists, and anyone keen on understanding a complex and often under-examined chapter of modern Indonesian history.