Le Manifeste Communiste de Marx et Engels - Tomes 1 et 2 Avec Commentaires

Name: Le Manifeste Communiste de Marx et Engels - Tomes 1 et 2 Avec Commentaires
Rating: 8.39 (444 reviews)
ISBN: 9781710930689

by ,

Language: French
Published in: 2019
Publisher: Independently Published
Pages: 134
ISBN: 9781710930689

Subjects

Original edition details

The Communist Manifesto Originally published in 1848

Original language

English

Original publisher Brian Westland

Other editions (214)

The Communist Manifesto (Annotated Edition)

2019 • Ancient Wisdom Publications

English

The Communist Manifesto [annotated]

2018 • Independently Published

English

The Communist Manifesto / The April Theses

2016 • Verso

English

The Communist Manifesto

2017 • Innovative Eggz LLC

English

Communist Manifesto (Illustrated) - Chapter Four The Communists

2015 • Working Girl Press

English

8.39 / 10 (444 ratings)

Reviews summary

Positives

Many readers found this collection of foundational texts, particularly The Communist Manifesto, to be a powerful and essential read. Reviewers frequently praised the Manifesto for its enduring relevance, noting how its critiques of economic and social systems written in the 19th century still resonate strikingly with contemporary issues. Its language is often described as witty, electric, and surprisingly accessible, making complex ideas clear and impactful. Lenin's accompanying writings, including The April Theses and Letters from Afar, are celebrated for providing a practical dimension to the theoretical framework of the Manifesto, illustrating how these ideas were considered for real-world application. Readers appreciated how the texts, when presented together, offered a more comprehensive understanding of revolutionary thought and historical context, deepening their engagement with the material. The introductions by Tariq Ali were also frequently commended for effectively setting the scene and guiding newcomers through the challenging subject matter.

Negatives

Despite the overall positive reception, several reviewers highlighted challenges, particularly for those new to the subject. A common point of difficulty was the historical specificity of Lenin's texts, with many finding them confusing and hard to follow without a strong pre-existing knowledge of early 20th-century Russian and European history. Some felt that the provided introductions or footnotes, while helpful, were not always sufficient for a complete novice, suggesting a need for more extensive contextualization. The academic nature of some sections and the dense political discussions meant the book was not always an easy or "thrilling" read, occasionally dragging for some. One reviewer also noted that certain editions might lack important prefaces from Marx and Engels, potentially missing valuable reflections. Furthermore, a few readers, while acknowledging the historical importance, expressed reservations about the ideological stances or the perceived failures of the concepts when applied in practice, finding some aspects outdated or too simplistic.

Conclusion

Overall, the collection is widely regarded as an indispensable and historically significant work that continues to provoke thought and discussion. Readers largely recommend it, emphasizing its importance for anyone seeking to understand fundamental political theories and their historical impact. This book is particularly suited for students of history and political science, individuals interested in the origins of socialist and communist thought, or those looking to deepen their understanding of critiques against capitalism. It is ideal for readers who appreciate engaging directly with original historical documents rather than secondary analyses and who are prepared to delve into complex ideas. While prior historical knowledge or a willingness to research can greatly enhance the reading experience, the core messages are often found to be remarkably clear and inspiring, making it a foundational text for anyone interested in political change and social justice.

No reviews yet. Be the first to review this book!

Rating sources

Subjects

Original edition details

Other editions (214)

The Communist Manifesto (Annotated Edition)

The Communist Manifesto [annotated]

The Communist Manifesto / The April Theses

The Communist Manifesto

Communist Manifesto (Illustrated) - Chapter Four The Communists