L'effet Rosie ou le Théorème de la cigogne

Reviewers who enjoyed The Rosie Effect often praised the return of Don Tillman, finding his unique voice, thought processes, and quirky personality as memorable and endearing as in the first installment. Many appreciated his good intentions, his methodical approach to life, and the humorous situations he inevitably found himself in, often managing to land on his feet despite challenges. Some readers found the story a thoroughly enjoyable and gripping read, filled with laugh-out-loud moments, and appreciated its light-hearted yet sometimes moving and thought-provoking nature. Don's journey of self-reflection and developing empathy was noted as an emotionally satisfying aspect, and some felt the sequel offered a more "real" and mature exploration of the characters. Fans also highlighted the continued charm of the characters and the overall fun ride the book provided.

Conversely, many reviewers expressed significant disappointment, feeling the sequel lacked the magic and charm of its predecessor. A common criticism revolved around a perceived lack of substantial plot, with the story often described as tedious, sluggish, and relying on contrived situations or recycled tropes. Reviewers frequently found the humor to be repetitive or absent altogether, with Don's "quirkiness" sometimes escalating to an annoying, over-the-top level. A major point of contention was the portrayal of Rosie, with many feeling her character lost her original charm, becoming two-dimensional, less pleasant, or a stereotypical "pregnant woman" who behaved childishly or irrationally. Some felt the book was male-centric, with other female characters also appearing hollow. The writing was occasionally criticized as poorly imagined or rushed, leading to a less engaging experience compared to the first book.

Ultimately, The Rosie Effect elicits a highly divided response, with readers split between those who found it a worthy continuation and those who felt it was a significant letdown. While Don Tillman's distinctive character remains a highlight for many, the changes in Rosie's portrayal and the perceived weaknesses in plot and humor proved to be major stumbling blocks for others. This book is likely to appeal most to readers who deeply enjoyed the first book's protagonist and are eager to revisit his unique perspective, even if the narrative tone shifts to be more serious or stressful at times. It is recommended for those who appreciate Don's unconventional problem-solving and can overlook a less robust plot or altered character dynamics in favor of his enduring charm.