Les Annales du disque-monde. Tome XV. Le Guet des orfèvres (S F ET FANTASTIQUE)

Reviewers overwhelmingly praise the book for its brilliant humor, sharp wit, and clever satire, often leading to genuine laughter. Many highlight how the author masterfully balances amusing text with engaging and compelling characters, noting their depth and evolution throughout the story. Specific characters like Captain Vimes and Captain Carrot are singled out for their strong presence and development, with Carrot often stealing the show. Beyond the comedy, the book is lauded for its insightful exploration of profound social themes such as racism, class distinctions, discrimination, and the impact of new technology, all handled with subtlety and without being preachy. The plot is described as refined, complex, and a gripping murder mystery, making it a fast-paced and thoroughly enjoyable read.

While overwhelmingly positive, a few minor points were raised. One reviewer felt that the series, at this point, might appear to take a step backward compared to the author's other works, although this was an outlier opinion. Another mentioned that the lack of chapters, a stylistic choice, could be perceived as a challenge by some readers, even if they ultimately overcame it for the sheer enjoyment of the book. A small wish was expressed for a particular character's storyline to have been more prominent, though this was acknowledged as a minor personal preference rather than a significant flaw.

Overall, the book is considered a brilliant and essential entry in its series, often cited as one of the author's finest works and a highlight of the City Watch storyline. It is highly recommended for both long-time fans and newcomers to the author's universe, serving as an excellent starting point for those interested in the City Watch sub-series. Readers who appreciate humorous fantasy combined with astute social commentary, well-developed characters, and a compelling mystery will find this book immensely rewarding. It offers a unique blend of entertainment and thoughtful reflection, making it a deeply satisfying read for anyone seeking sharp wit and a hopeful, yet grounded, view of human nature.