Lo catalanisme (Catalan Edition)

The book is highly praised for its exploration of Valentí Almirall's political thought, which is considered prodigious within its historical context. Reviewers highlight its valuable insights into particularism, not as a divine concept of Catalan identity, but as a federalist system. The work effectively links Catalanism to the federal application of Catalan particularity, grounded in historical and linguistic essence. It is particularly interesting for understanding the intellectual movements of Catalanism at the close of the 19th and dawn of the 20th centuries, further enriching its analysis with practical federalist applications drawn from other countries.

Despite its strengths, some readers found the book to be a bit too long. A key critique is that Almirall's thought, while historically significant, may not be directly applicable to contemporary Catalan reality. Additionally, the practical examples of federalism drawn from other nations, such as the USA, Germany, or Great Britain, are noted to derive from historical contexts that are now significantly different.

Overall, the book offers a fascinating glimpse into a pivotal period of political thought, making it a valuable historical document. While its direct relevance to current political situations is questioned and its length noted, it remains an essential read for those interested in the intellectual history of Catalanism, federalist theories, and the political ideas of the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Readers who appreciate detailed historical analysis and the evolution of political thought will likely find this book rewarding.