Positives Many reviewers praise the book as a powerful and important work, describing it as a psychodrama, melodrama, and crime drama that delves into sociological horror and acts as a feminist manifesto. The author is commended for creating a brilliantly dark and grotesque literary form, skillfully critiquing machismo and classism. Readers found the writing robust, vigorous, detailed, and gorgeous, noting its ability to seep into the reader's consciousness like a potent poison. The novel is lauded for its clever structure, gradually revealing the dark side of privilege and self-satisfaction. It is frequently highlighted as a harrowing yet necessary read, impossible to finish unscathed, and a valuable tool for memory, offering a powerful indictment against toxic masculinity in its widest sense. Many found it engaging, authentic, and compelling, prompting important reflections on societal violence and impunity.
Negatives Despite the strong praise, a significant number of reviews expressed disappointment with various aspects of the book. Some found it difficult to get into the narration initially, describing the pace as slow, rambling, and at times heavy or even "interminable." Several reviewers felt the characters, particularly the group of friends, were underdeveloped, superficial, childish, or caricaturish, with their actions and dialogue often feeling artificial or unconvincing. The narrator, in particular, was singled out by some as unlikeable, unbelievable, or "insoportable." Critics mentioned that the author's characteristic "magic" or critical social portrait was absent, and that the novel fell short in effectively conveying the widespread anger and indignation felt by the nation regarding the real-life events that inspired it. The language was also a point of contention, with some finding it forced, repetitive, or laden with specific cultural references that hindered their reading experience.
Conclusion Overall, this book emerges as a challenging and thought-provoking read, highly valued for its thematic depth and social commentary, even if its execution divided opinions. It is recommended for readers seeking a dark, introspective novel that explores toxic masculinity, class privilege, and the nuances of complicity in horrific acts, rather than a straightforward true crime narrative. Those who appreciate literary explorations of uncomfortable social truths, can tolerate a deliberate pace, and are willing to grapple with complex character dynamics will likely find this an important and impactful experience. However, readers looking for a fast-paced plot, easily relatable characters, or a more direct focus on the victim's perspective might find it less satisfying. The book ultimately serves as a stark reminder of societal issues and the need for collective introspection.
