Anne Shirley embarks on a new chapter as she leaves the beloved shores of Prince Edward Island for Redmond College in Kingsport, Nova Scotia, to pursue her dreams of higher education. Surrounded by old friends like Gilbert Blythe and new companions such as the charming Philippa Gordon, Anne navigates the bustling world of university life, settling into a cozy cottage and embracing academic challenges.
As Anne matures from a spirited girl into a thoughtful young woman, she grapples with the complexities of friendship, the pangs of first love, and the pursuit of her own identity. She encounters various suitors and explores her romantic ideals, learning that true affection often reveals itself in unexpected ways. This journey of self-discovery, marked by both triumphs and poignant moments, ultimately leads Anne to a deeper understanding of her heart's true desires and the enduring bonds that tie her to the people and the island she calls home.
The familiar red roads of Prince Edward Island stretched behind her as Anne Shirley, now a young woman of eighteen, set out for Redmond College in Kingsport, Nova Scotia. It was a grand adventure, a fulfillment of her long-held dream of higher education, though leaving Green Gables and the steadfast comfort of Marilla, Davy, and Dora tugged at her heart. Gilbert Blythe, ever the loyal companion and rival, was bound for Redmond too, as was Priscilla Grant, a dear friend from Queen's. The world, it seemed, was expanding, and Anne, with her vivid imagination and boundless spirit, was ready to embrace it.
The first year at college was a whirl of new experiences and friendships. Anne found herself drawn to Philippa Gordon, or Phil, a charming, beautiful, and delightfully frivolous girl from Anne's own birthplace, Bolingbroke. Together with Priscilla, they navigated the bustling life of boarding houses. The following year, their dreams of a shared home materialized in the cozy, sun-drenched cottage they christened Patty's Place, where Stella Maynard and the kindly chaperone, Aunt Jamesina, joined their lively household. Within those walls, amidst studies and laughter, their bond deepened, a testament to the enduring power of female friendship.
Life, however, was not without its shadows, even in the bright glow of youth. News from Avonlea brought sorrow when Anne learned of Ruby Gillis's rapid decline from consumption. Anne rushed home, spending precious time at her friend's bedside, witnessing Ruby's poignant longing for love and life, a stark reminder of the fragile beauty of existence. It was a sobering experience that etched itself onto Anne's heart, urging her to savor every moment and to cherish those around her.
Amidst the academic pursuits and the vibrant camaraderie of Patty's Place, the question of love began to weave its way into Anne's thoughts. Gilbert Blythe, whose devotion had been a quiet, constant presence for years, finally spoke his heart, proposing marriage. But Anne, still clinging to a romantic ideal of a tall, dark, and inscrutable hero, gently refused him, believing her feelings for Gilbert were merely those of a dear friend. The rejection wounded Gilbert deeply, and a noticeable distance grew between them, leaving Anne with an unexpected ache.
Then came Roy Gardner, a handsome Redmond student who fit Anne's aesthetic ideal perfectly. He courted her with poetic gestures and unwavering attention, and Anne found herself drawn into a two-year courtship, believing she had finally found the thrilling, romantic love she had always dreamed of. She became close to his sister, Dorothy, and for a time, it seemed her path was clear. Yet, beneath the surface of his charming devotion, Anne began to sense a certain dullness, a lack of the sparkling, kindred spirit she truly craved.
The culmination of her college years brought another proposal from Roy, but this time, Anne understood. Her heart, which had sought grand pronouncements and dramatic passion, now recognized a deeper truth. Roy was not her destiny. The realization left her feeling a profound sense of relief, but also a quiet confusion about her own heart.
It was a letter from Phil, full of news and gentle wisdom, that revealed the true state of Gilbert's feelings, assuring Anne that there was nothing between Gilbert and a certain Christine. Then, a terrifying whisper reached her: Gilbert was gravely ill with typhoid fever, hovering between life and death. In that moment of agonizing fear, as she grappled with the terrifying possibility of losing him forever, Anne's heart finally opened, recognizing the profound, undeniable love she held for Gilbert Blythe. The romantic fantasies of her youth shattered, replaced by the deep, abiding truth of a love that had always been there, steady and true.
As the dawn broke, bringing with it the joyous news of Gilbert's recovery, a wave of profound gratitude washed over Anne. She had almost lost the truest love of her life, the one who understood her utterly, the one whose spirit mirrored her own. When Gilbert, still pale but recovering, returned to Green Gables and proposed once more, Anne accepted without hesitation. The journey through Redmond, with its friendships, heartaches, and lessons, had brought her home, not just to Prince Edward Island, but to the home of her own heart, to the man who had been patiently waiting for her all along.
What other readers say
Liked
Many readers found "Anne of the Island" to be their favorite installment in the series, praising its beautiful writing, immersive settings, and charming storylines. Reviewers consistently highlighted the delightful experience of following Anne as she matures into a young woman, navigating college life and forming new friendships, all while retaining her beloved core spirit. The book is celebrated for capturing both the joyful and wistful aspects of growing up, offering a comforting and engaging read. Both new and returning characters were described as lovely and relatable, contributing to the series' enduring humor and emotional depth, with many appreciating Anne's academic pursuits and burgeoning independence.
Disliked
However, the book also drew some criticism from readers. A common concern was a perceived repetitiveness in plot structures and a tendency for challenges to be resolved with excessive ease, leading to an overly idyllic or "perfect" world. Some reviewers felt Anne's character became too flawless or "Mary Sue"-like, losing some of the relatable imperfections seen in earlier books, and found her occasionally moralistic. The diminished presence of long-standing friendships, such as with Diana, was a point of disappointment for several. A significant number of readers were particularly disturbed by scenes depicting casual or attempted animal harm, finding these moments jarring, out of character for Anne, and difficult to reconcile with the overall tone. Additionally, some found the romantic developments predictable and drawn out, with Anne's numerous proposals feeling unrealistic or tedious.
In short
Overall, "Anne of the Island" remains a cherished entry in the series for many, continuing to offer the warmth, humor, and emotional depth that readers have come to expect. While it thoughtfully explores the protagonist's transition into young adulthood with its complexities and moments of self-discovery, it also features some narrative choices and character portrayals that may not resonate with all contemporary readers. This book is highly recommended for fans of classic coming-of-age stories, particularly those who enjoy character-driven narratives focusing on female friendships, academic life, and gentle romance. It will especially appeal to those who appreciate immersive settings, reflective prose, and stories about personal development and the enduring power of imagination, even when acknowledging the historical context of certain dated elements.