Positives Readers largely praised this volume for its pure fun, comedy, and focus on friendship. The introduction of roller derby was a particular highlight, described as "perfection," "awesome," and "epic," blending seamlessly with the series' established tone. Fans enjoyed the return of popular characters like the Yetis and Sasquatches, along with the continued development of existing characters, including the positive portrayal and acceptance of gender-neutral pronouns. The story was celebrated for its crisp storytelling, heart, hijinks, and overall pleasing blend of fantasy, comedy, adventure, and action, providing a refreshing and enjoyable read. Many found it to be a classic "Lumberjanes" experience, full of the series' signature charm and diverse cast.
Negatives However, the volume was not without its criticisms. A significant point of contention for several readers was the change in artwork, with some expressing strong dislike for the new style and noting differences in character appearances. Beyond the visuals, some reviewers felt the plot lacked substance, action, or mystery, leading to disappointment and a sense that the story was a "mishmash" or simply "okay." For long-time followers, there was a feeling of repetition, with the series' schema becoming predictable. A few also expressed concern that the otherwise appreciated diverse representation felt heavy-handed or "over the top" in this particular installment, moving beyond acceptance into what some perceived as agitation.
Conclusion Despite these mixed reactions, the general consensus indicates that this volume remains a fun and enjoyable read for many, especially those already invested in the series. While some consider it a weaker entry in an otherwise beloved "rollercoaster" series, its core strengths of humor, friendship, and unique adventures still shine through. This book is highly recommended for existing fans of the Lumberjanes who appreciate its blend of fantasy, comedy, and action, as well as new readers looking for a diverse and inclusive story with a lighthearted tone and a strong emphasis on positive relationships and acceptance. It serves as a nice break from darker narratives and continues to be seen as a series with the potential for enduring appeal.
