M. C. Escher: from Drawing to Masterpiece

Reviewers consistently praise this book as an excellent and definitive resource for M.C. Escher's work, particularly highlighting the extensive and complete catalog of his graphic art found in the latter half. This comprehensive collection is described as fantastic, a treasury, and a must-have for any admirer, often containing hundreds of illustrations. Many appreciate the detailed reproductions, which allow readers to explore the mathematical precision and intricate details of his art. Beyond the catalog, the book is valued for including insightful essays by Escher himself and others, which delve into the mathematical underpinnings of his work and his unique creative processes, sometimes even providing preliminary diagrams. The biographical sections are also noted for offering a thorough discussion of his life, travels, and major events, often supplemented by his personal correspondence, which provides valuable perspectives on his work and state of mind.

Despite its strengths, the book receives some criticism regarding its textual content, particularly the biographical sections. Some reviewers found the biography less engaging, feeling that it omitted certain desired details of Escher's life or relied too heavily on unsummarized personal letters rather than offering deeper insights into his character or motivations. A recurring point of contention is the perceived lack of extensive analysis or discussion about the artworks themselves, with the book leaning more towards a biographical account followed by a catalog, rather than a detailed art critique. Practical issues such as the catalog predominantly featuring black and white reproductions, which some feel diminishes the full value of the art, and difficulties in navigating between textual references and corresponding images, are also mentioned as detracting from the overall reading experience.

Overall, this volume is considered a highly valuable and essential compendium for anyone interested in M.C. Escher, despite its unevenness in textual presentation. It is particularly recommended as an excellent starting point for those new to Escher's work, as well as a definitive resource for long-time enthusiasts seeking a comprehensive collection of his prints. Readers who prioritize a complete visual catalog of Escher's art, along with insights from his own writings and a factual overview of his life, will find this book immensely rewarding. While those seeking a deeply analytical art history or a more intimately rendered biography might find aspects of the text wanting, the sheer breadth of Escher's reproduced work and the inclusion of his own intellectual contributions make this a foundational piece for any Escher library.