M pour Mabel

The book is widely praised for its fascinating subject matter, offering an in-depth look at the cultural history and natural history of falcons. Reviewers consistently found it to be highly informative, packed with interesting facts about the birds' biology, behavior, and their historical relationship with humanity. Helen Macdonald's prose is frequently described as engaging, lyrical, and passionate, making the complex information accessible and captivating for a broad audience. Readers appreciated the extensive exploration of how falcons have been perceived and utilized across various cultures and centuries, serving as symbols of nobility, power, and even military prowess. The discussion of conservation efforts and the successful rehabilitation of falcon populations, particularly after periods of decline, also garnered positive attention. Many highlighted the book's beautiful illustrations and its contribution to a well-regarded series on animals.

However, some readers expressed disappointment, particularly when comparing it to the author's later, more acclaimed work. They found this earlier effort to be less personal and emotionally resonant, leading to a "drier" reading experience for those expecting a memoir-style narrative. One significant critique pointed to issues with the translation in a non-English edition, which was described as distracting and at times hindering comprehension. Structural concerns were also raised, with some finding the presentation of facts occasionally disjointed or lacking a clear chronological flow, at times feeling more like a collection of trivia. Additionally, some reviewers felt the book could have offered a deeper critical analysis, particularly regarding anthropocentric views and gendered language used in describing falcons and falconry, and noted a perceived imbalance in geographical focus in certain chapters.

Despite these criticisms, "Falcon" is largely considered a valuable and highly readable book that successfully conveys the author's deep fascination with these remarkable birds. It offers a rich tapestry of information about falcons, their interaction with human societies, and their enduring symbolic significance. This book is highly recommended for anyone with a keen interest in natural history, raptors, the intricate relationship between humans and animals, or the cultural impact of wildlife. While fans of the author's more personal narratives might find it different, those looking for an objective, fact-rich exploration of a captivating species will likely find it a rewarding read.