Positives Reviewers widely praise this Maigret novel as an engaging and delightful entry in the series, highlighting its strong story and atmospheric quality. Many found it a treat, commending Georges Simenon's masterful writing and his deep understanding of Chief Inspector Maigret, portraying him as a profoundly human, compassionate, and empathetic character. The narrative is noted for bringing Maigret's wife into focus and for its unique start, diverging from a typical crime investigation. A significant highlight is Maigret's journey to London, offering amusing cultural contrasts and observations as the detective finds himself out of his usual Parisian milieu. Readers appreciated the author's subtle humor, particularly concerning Maigret's thoughts on food and British licensing laws. The audiobook narration by Gareth Armstrong also received consistent acclaim for bringing the characters, especially Maigret, vividly to life.
Negatives While generally well-received, some reviewers noted that the plot itself is not always the most exciting or complex, occasionally feeling light or less thrilling compared to other entries. A few readers found the story's pace slower than usual, and some felt that the ending could be perceived as inconclusive, with certain questions left unanswered or justice not immediately dispensed. There were also observations regarding the portrayal of female characters, with some noting the presence of "sexism of the day" in descriptions. Additionally, Maigret's significant alcohol consumption throughout the story was mentioned, sometimes with amusement, but occasionally as an excessive detail. Some opinions described the book as merely "average" for the series, or not quite what they expected from a traditional mystery.
Conclusion Despite these minor reservations, the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many considering this novel to be one of the best in the Maigret canon. It is highly recommended for those who appreciate character-driven mysteries, where the psychological aspects of crime and the humanity of the detective take precedence over intricate, fast-paced plots. Readers seeking a balanced blend of intrigue, atmospheric detail, and the unique charm of Maigret's compassionate approach to his cases will find this a deeply satisfying read. It is also an excellent choice for listeners who enjoy strong narration, and for anyone looking for an engaging distraction that offers a glimpse into a bygone era through the eyes of a beloved detective.
