Mengenal dan Mewaspadai Penyimpangan Syi'ah di Indonesia

This book is widely praised as the result of extensive, scientific, and objective research conducted by a team of respected scholars from the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI). Reviewers highlight its fair and balanced approach, distinguishing it from other books on the subject that are often perceived as overly biased. It offers a comprehensive overview, covering historical context, doctrinal differences, and the movement's presence within Indonesia, concluding with the official stance of MUI and the perspectives of various Indonesian ulemas. Readers found it to be an informative and up-to-date guide, useful for gaining deeper knowledge and understanding, with its compact size making it convenient for casual reading.

However, the book is not without its criticisms. A notable point of contention for early editions was a factual error, specifically the incorrect identification of a Sunni organization as part of the discussed group, although this error was subsequently clarified and corrected in later printings. More fundamentally, one reviewer raises a concern about the book's underlying premise, questioning whether its approach to defining "correct" Islamic understanding might inadvertently contribute to an aversion to pluralism within the diverse landscape of Islamic thought, particularly when institutional bodies are seen as arbiters of religious truth.

Overall, the book serves as an authoritative and well-researched resource for those seeking to understand a particular school of thought from the perspective of the Indonesian Ulema Council. It is particularly suited for Muslim readers in Indonesia who are looking for an official and clear guide on the subject, aiming to inform themselves about different Islamic understandings and to safeguard their own beliefs. Readers who appreciate a book that takes a clear and decisive stance on religious matters, offering a definitive conclusion on the topic, would likely find this book valuable.