Najdīyūn warāʾa al-ḥudūd al-ʻAqīlāt wa-dawruhum fī ʻalāqat Najd al-a1askarīyah wa-al-iqtiṣādīyah bi-al-ʻIrāq wa-al-Shām wa- Miṣr (1750m-1950m)

The book is widely praised for its comprehensive and well-researched documentary style, meticulously tracing the Aqaylat's 200-year history. Readers commend the author's extensive effort in gathering information, facts, evidence, photos, and appendices, which provide a deep dive into who the Aqaylat were, their origins, and their significant role in the Arabian Peninsula's history, particularly before World War I and the subsequent border divisions. The author's engaging writing style is noted, as is his ability to transport readers to historical settings like the Najd desert, the Sawad region, and ancient trade routes. The book effectively explores their military and political roles under Ottoman rule, their trade routes from Najd to the Levant and Iraq to Aleppo, and their struggle for livelihood. It also sheds light on their distinct identity as urban dwellers from Najd, their role in protecting and managing trade caravans, and their function as a link between Bedouins and Ottomans. The author's expertise in European travelers' accounts of the Arabian Peninsula is also highlighted, as he frequently cites them to support his narrative.

Despite the wealth of detail, some readers found the extensive information overwhelming, leading to occasional boredom. A significant criticism raised is the presence of numerous date errors, which is particularly concerning for a second edition of a historical work, potentially affecting the accuracy of the historical timeline presented.

Overall, the book is highly recommended as a beautiful, enjoyable, and enlightening read that offers a unique perspective on the Aqaylat's human heritage. It delves into their economic, social, and military aspects, challenging popular notions about their origins and identity. This book would appeal to readers interested in the history of the Arabian Peninsula, particularly those curious about the social, economic, military, and political dynamics of the region's communities, their trade networks, and their interactions with larger empires like the Ottomans. It is a valuable resource for anyone wishing to understand the intricate history and struggles of a significant group often overlooked in broader historical narratives.