Norrøn religion myter, riter, samfunn

The book is widely praised as one of the best single-volume summaries and introductions to Norse religion, particularly from a religious studies and historical research perspective. Reviewers commend its comprehensive coverage, delving into ancient myths, everyday beliefs such as spirits, rune spells, and galdrs, as well as various rites. It effectively explains how Norse religion reflected social order and permeated daily life in the Viking Age. Many found the work to be thorough, well-documented, and nuanced, especially when discussing areas of ongoing academic debate. The inclusion of archaeological insights and illustrative photographs, along with atmospheric landscape images, enhances the reading experience. Readers appreciate its accessibility, making complex topics understandable for both academics and non-specialists, and it is noted for enriching understanding by presenting different interpretations and unresolved questions in the field. The author's inclusion of a gender perspective is also highlighted as a valuable aspect.

Despite its strengths, the book receives criticism on several fronts. Some readers found the language dense and challenging, particularly for those reading in a non-native language, with even native speakers struggling with certain vocabulary. A significant recurring complaint is the text's repetitiveness, leading some to suggest it functions better as a reference work for specific topics rather than a continuous read. More critical reviews point to issues with poor language, circular argumentation, incorrect source references, flawed translations, weak arguments, and unsubstantiated conclusions. The book's treatment of queer theory is also noted as a missed opportunity, with the author seemingly dismissing relevant perspectives or failing to apply a queer lens where it could have been insightful. Additionally, two specific factual errors regarding a mythological weapon and the capacity of a famous ship are highlighted. Finally, some reviewers disagree with the author's pronounced view on the origins of Old Norse religion, specifically its perceived connection to certain ancient traditions, arguing that this approach oversimplifies the deities by categorizing them and potentially overlooking their unique, independent development.

Overall, this book stands out as a highly regarded academic work offering a deep dive into Norse religion and the scholarly research surrounding it. While it provides a comprehensive and nuanced overview, potential readers should be aware of the stylistic challenges and specific academic interpretations that have drawn criticism. It is highly recommended for those seeking a rigorous, academically oriented introduction to Norse religion from a history of religion perspective, particularly students or curious non-academics willing to engage with a detailed and sometimes demanding text. Those who appreciate a thorough exploration of scholarly debates, the integration of archaeology, and a broader gender perspective will likely find this book valuable. However, readers looking for a simple, unproblematic narrative of Norse mythology or those sensitive to repetition and specific academic viewpoints on religious origins might consider other options.