Reviewers largely praise the book as an engaging sequel that continues the improbable adventures of its beloved characters, often with the same characteristic style and humor found in the first installment. Many found it to be a witty, zany, and immensely readable experience, with some even declaring it superior to its predecessor. The narrative is lauded for its absurd genialities, imaginative concepts, and the author's ability to fuse science fiction, fantasy, humor, and philosophy into a unique intergalactic journey. Readers highlighted the clever ideas, the exploration of deep topics like time, human evolution, and the cosmic scale, all delivered with perfectly crafted lines that often elicit laughter. Marvin the Paranoid Android consistently stands out as a favorite character, "brightening up" the day with his gloomy disposition.
Disliked
However, the book also drew criticism, primarily concerning its humor and plot. Some reviewers felt the humor, while present, did not always land as effectively as in the first book, describing it as less sharp, clumsy, or even outdated and infantile. The surprise element from the original was perceived to be lost for some. Plotting was frequently described as weak, lazy, or lacking a strong central interest, with some readers finding it difficult to maintain engagement due to a perceived lack of clear direction or character development. Character portrayals also received mixed reactions, with Zaphod sometimes found to be excessively grumpy and unpleasant, and other main characters like Trillian, Arthur, and Ford having limited presence or impact for much of the story. For some, the high standard set by the first book proved too challenging for the sequel to meet.
In short
Ultimately, the reviews indicate a book that, despite its divisive aspects, remains a memorable and often enjoyable part of the series. While not universally adored, it is frequently seen as a worthy continuation that delves deeper into philosophical satire and maintains its distinctive voice. This book is best suited for readers who appreciated the unique blend of science fiction, philosophical musings, and absurd British humor from the previous installment and are less concerned with conventional plot structures. It appeals to those who enjoy thought-provoking concepts, witty one-liners, and a universe that delights in its own chaotic unpredictability, even if the journey occasionally feels less focused.