Omen 4: Malam Karnaval Berdarah

This installment of the series garnered significant praise, primarily for its focus on the romantic interactions between the main characters, Rima and Daniel. Many readers enthusiastically enjoyed their developing chemistry, finding their moments endearing, well-written, and a highlight of the book. The dual perspectives of Rima and Daniel were largely appreciated, with some noting Daniel's viewpoint added a fresh, humorous dimension. Despite mixed opinions on the mystery, several reviewers found the plot engaging, full of unexpected twists, and adept at making them question various assumptions. Lexie Xu's characteristic writing style, her ability to craft compelling characters, and her skill in creating an immersive narrative were also frequently commended.

However, the book also drew considerable criticism, mainly regarding its pacing and the intensity of its thriller elements. A common complaint was that the story felt drawn out in parts, with the climax perceived as too brief. Many readers felt the mystery aspect was less gripping or suspenseful compared to previous books in the series, often overshadowed by the romance, to the point where the thriller genre felt more like a secondary element. The ending, which left many questions unanswered, was a significant point of contention, with some finding it too abrupt, random, or unsatisfyingly unresolved. Some reviewers also noted difficulties distinguishing between Rima and Daniel's narrative voices and expressed disappointment over the limited appearances of other beloved characters from the series. Minor issues like typos were also mentioned.

Overall, this book appears to be a mixed bag, with its strengths lying in character relationships and its weaknesses in maintaining a consistent thriller intensity. It is likely to appeal most to readers who are deeply invested in the romantic arc of Rima and Daniel and enjoy a lighter mystery with strong character development. Fans of Lexie Xu's signature style and those who appreciate stories that blend romance with a touch of suspense, even if the ending is a cliffhanger, will likely find enjoyment here, especially if they are already following the series.