On Ugliness /anglais

Umberto Eco's "On Ugliness" is widely praised for its ambitious and unique concept, serving as a comprehensive counterpoint to his earlier work on beauty. Reviewers consistently highlight the book's extraordinary erudition, showcasing Eco's vast knowledge across art history, philosophy, literature, and mythology. The volume is lauded for its lavish production, featuring numerous stunning full-color illustrations that make it a visually rich and engaging experience. Many find the book profoundly thought-provoking, as it explores the relative and culturally constructed nature of ugliness, challenging conventional perceptions and revealing humanity's enduring fascination with the monstrous and the grotesque throughout history. Its extensive collection of primary source excerpts and artistic depictions is considered a valuable resource for understanding this often-neglected aspect of human culture.

Despite its strengths, some readers found the book's structure to be less cohesive than anticipated, perceiving it more as a curated anthology or catalog of items rather than a deeply analytical or historically progressive narrative. The accompanying commentary is occasionally described as sparse, superficial, or overly generalist, leaving some longing for more in-depth theoretical or psychological analysis. Critics also note that the book can assume a significant prior knowledge of classics, philosophy, and art history, which might make it challenging for readers without such a background. Furthermore, the sheer volume of text fragments, while extensive, was at times found to be repetitive or disjointed, making a cover-to-cover read feel like a laborious task.

Overall, "On Ugliness" stands as a monumental and significant contribution to the study of aesthetics, offering an unparalleled historical compendium of how the concept of ugliness has been perceived and represented. While it may not always provide the deep analytical dives some readers seek, its strength lies in its expansive scope and visual richness, making it an excellent reference work. This book is particularly recommended for readers with an existing interest in art history, philosophy, and literature who appreciate broad, visually driven explorations of complex cultural concepts. It appeals to those fascinated by the dark, the abject, and the evolution of aesthetic values, serving as an illuminating introduction to the theory of ugliness and an invitation to further contemplation.