Positives Eric Bogosian's book is widely praised as an exceptionally informative and gripping account of a lesser-known yet crucial historical event. Reviewers consistently highlight its ability to shed light on the Armenian Genocide and the subsequent Operation Nemesis, an assassination plot by Armenian survivors seeking retribution. Many found the narrative to be engaging and compelling, often reading like a thrilling espionage novel despite its non-fiction nature. The book is commended for its thorough research, providing extensive historical context of Armenian and Ottoman relations, and for its detailed examination of the assassination missions and the ensuing highly publicized trials. Readers appreciated the author's passionate yet clear prose, which maintains attention throughout the book's various sections, and his skill in making complex history accessible to a broad audience.
Negatives Despite the widespread acclaim, some reviewers expressed reservations. A few noted that the author, an actor and playwright, is not a professional historian, though many others defended the soundness of his research. Concerns were raised about potential bias due to Bogosian's Armenian heritage and personal family connection to the genocide, with some critics suggesting he was not entirely impartial and, in some instances, too sympathetic to the assassins. One reviewer specifically accused the book of containing "questionable history," mixing facts with fiction, and being one-sided in its justification of certain actions. Others found the book's scope too ambitious, covering too much ancient and modern Armenian history, which occasionally led to a long-winded narrative and a less focused exploration of Operation Nemesis itself.
Conclusion Overall, Operation Nemesis is highly recommended as a powerful and thought-provoking work that illuminates a significant and often overlooked chapter of history. It offers a vital perspective on themes of justice, vengeance, and the enduring power of memory in the face of unacknowledged atrocities. This book will particularly appeal to readers interested in the Armenian Genocide, the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and the ethical complexities of retribution. It is also well-suited for those who appreciate engaging non-fiction that combines rigorous research with a narrative style akin to a historical thriller.
