Positives This collection of sermons by St. Gregory of Nazianzus is widely praised for its profound theological insights and remarkable oratorical skill. Reviewers consistently highlight Gregory's incredible mind, his ability to weave Trinitarian theology throughout his homilies, and his eloquent explanation of complex doctrines in an accessible manner. The book is lauded as an excellent introduction to his thought, with the translation receiving particular acclaim for preserving Gregory's wit and poetic style. Many found the sermons inspiring, clear, and deeply saturated with Holy Scriptures, bringing ancient Christian feasts to life and demonstrating their enduring theological and rhetorical power, making them feel relevant even today. The superb introduction by Nonna Harrison is frequently commended for its scholarly depth and helpful context, enhancing the overall value of this beautifully edited collection.
Negatives However, some reviewers expressed minor reservations. A common point was the occasional repetitiveness within the content, particularly regarding certain exhortations. Not all orations were considered equal in quality, and some readers found parts of the sermons cumbersome or challenging to follow at times. One critique noted a perceived "Platonized" influence in Gregory's thought, suggesting a negative view of physicality despite the emphasis on the incarnation. Additionally, Gregory's theology on specific topics, such as baptism, was described by some as appearing inconsistent or "all over the place," potentially making it less straightforward for certain readers.
Conclusion Overall, this is considered a highly valuable and well-presented collection, offering a rich blend of theology and festal proclamation. Despite the minor criticisms regarding repetitiveness or complexity in certain sections, the book is strongly recommended as an excellent introduction to the writings of St. Gregory of Nazianzus. It will particularly appeal to readers interested in Cappadocian theology, patristic studies, or those seeking a deeper understanding of the historical roots of Christian feast days and hymnody. Many reviewers consider it a significant and rewarding read, worthy of being revisited time and again for its lasting theological and rhetorical impact.
