Positives Reviewers widely praise Paweł Smoleński as a master of reportage, whose collection of articles, originally written around the turn of the millennium, sharply captures the spirit and atmosphere of that era. The book is lauded for its courageous and uncompromising approach, prioritizing truth and justice over narrow patriotism. Smoleński is commended for his balanced perspective, giving voice to various experiences and allowing characters to share their traumas without taking sides. Many found the book deeply touching and impactful, appreciating its ability to raise profound, timeless questions about identity and humanity, making it relevant for any reader in the 21st century.
Negatives The main critique noted by some reviewers is the absence of a contemporary perspective, as the reports were compiled over two decades ago. While this historical context is inherent to the book's original publication, some readers expressed a desire for an updated viewpoint, particularly in light of more recent geopolitical developments. However, other reviewers also highlighted that despite its age, the book's themes and insights have gained renewed relevance and continue to resonate with current public discourse.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a wise, courageous, and powerful work that encourages deep reflection on complex historical events and their enduring impact. It is highly recommended for readers interested in the intricate and often painful history of Polish-Ukrainian relations, as well as the broader themes of reconciliation, collective memory, and the pursuit of truth. It particularly appeals to those who value journalism that unflinchingly confronts uncomfortable historical narratives and prompts fundamental questions about societal identity and the importance of learning from the past to foster a more humane future.
