Politik Tiga Wajah

The book reportedly presents observations from a study focusing on the Chinese ethnic group in West Kalimantan. It aims to explore ethnic relations within society, touching upon the socio-psychological conditions of the nation and the concept of establishing a harmonious social environment between various ethnic groups in Indonesia, particularly during the New Order era.

However, the reviews heavily criticize the book for being deeply ethnocentric and exhibiting a strong anti-Chinese and pro-New Order bias. Reviewers assert that the author presents personal perceptions and generalizations as empirically researched opinions, lacking academic neutrality and critical thinking. It is described as arguably the shallowest academic book one reviewer has encountered, making it unsuitable as a scientific reference due to its highly subjective nature. The book is seen as a relic of the New Order, promoting assimilationist policies and reinforcing prejudice against the Chinese ethnic group by linking them to communism. Critics accuse the author of carrying hatred in their writing, contributing to division rather than fostering national unity.

Overall, the book is deemed highly problematic by reviewers, who question its academic integrity and suitability for publication or scholarly use. It is widely regarded as a subjective, biased work that serves as propaganda rather than a balanced academic study. While strongly advised against for use as a reliable scientific reference, some reviewers suggest it could be valuable for academics studying "bad scientific books" or as a case study of New Order-era propaganda. This book would likely appeal to readers interested in understanding historical biases and the impact of propaganda on ethnic relations, rather than those seeking objective and well-researched academic discourse.