Polskie Zudzenia Narodowe (Polish Edition)

This book is widely praised for its ability to challenge and re-evaluate established national myths, clearing them of what some perceive as propagandistic distortions. Readers found it to be a very interesting and engaging read, appreciating the author's erudition and storytelling, particularly when delving into less-known aspects of historical figures and events. Many found the book enlightening, learning a great deal and enjoying its lively language, which often incorporates a sharp, even sarcastic sense of humor. It is seen as a valuable resource for those willing to confront difficult and sometimes somber historical truths with a fresh perspective.

However, some readers expressed significant concerns regarding the author's methodology in presenting arguments. Criticisms include the tendency to generalize broad conclusions from limited literary examples, selective presentation of data, and potentially misrepresenting definitions or omitting crucial context. Specific examples cited involve the discussion of historical alcohol consumption, where the author is perceived as presenting a one-sided view or manipulating figures to support a particular thesis. This has led some to feel that the author occasionally "bends reality" or plays the role of a "devil's advocate," leading to a desire for a more balanced historical polemic.

Overall, despite the methodological controversies, the book is considered a thought-provoking and important read for those with open minds, particularly history enthusiasts eager to shed national illusions and critically examine their country's past. It is recommended for readers who appreciate a challenging narrative and a provocative style, even if it means encountering arguments that might be perceived as biased or selectively presented. Conversely, readers who prioritize rigorous academic methodology, exhaustive sourcing, and strict impartiality might find some aspects of the book's approach frustrating.