P.S. I Still Love You

Many readers found this book to be a sweet, cute, and thoroughly enjoyable contemporary read, praising Jenny Han's captivating writing style that made it difficult to put down. A standout positive was the strong portrayal of family dynamics, with the close-knit bond between the Song sisters and their supportive father receiving consistent acclaim. Lara Jean's character, with her unique hobbies like crafting and baking, was seen as endearing and relatable by many, and some appreciated her continued growth. The book was also commended for its realistic depiction of a developing romance, showcasing the natural ups and downs rather than an idealized, flawless relationship. The introduction of a new character, John Ambrose McClaren, was a significant highlight, with many reviewers finding him charming and delightful. Furthermore, the story was noted for its exploration of Korean American culture and for touching on themes of sexism and feminism.

Despite its strengths, the book garnered considerable criticism, with many reviewers expressing frustration over what they perceived as a lack of substantial plot and an abundance of "unnecessary drama." A frequent complaint centered on Peter Kavinsky's character, whose actions and perceived manipulation of situations often left readers annoyed and disappointed. Lara Jean's character also drew criticism, with some finding her indecisive, overly emotional, or even regressing in her development, leading to a sense of exasperation. The pacing was described as slow and overly domestic by some, with too many mundane details detracting from the narrative. The reintroduction of a "love triangle" was a common point of contention, with many feeling it was forced or poorly handled. Additionally, some reviewers found the relationship dynamics unrealistic or childish, and the ending was frequently criticized for feeling abrupt, rushed, or failing to provide a satisfying resolution to the conflicts.

Overall, this book evokes strong and divided opinions among its readers. While some found it a heartfelt and engaging continuation of the series, others felt it fell short of expectations due to its perceived lack of direction and frustrating character arcs. It is likely to appeal most to readers who enjoyed the first book, appreciate character-driven contemporary young adult romance, and value strong family relationships within a story. Readers who are looking for a light, emotionally resonant read that explores the complexities of first love and navigating teenage relationships, even with their inherent messiness and drama, will likely find something to enjoy. However, those who prefer a faster-paced plot, clear-cut resolutions, and less romantic angst may find themselves less satisfied.