Positives The book is widely praised for its accessibility, being described as an easy, fast-paced, and relatively short read. Reviewers consistently highlight its captivating and compelling narrative, often commending the author's engaging prose that skillfully combines reportage with personal observations. Many found it a timely and relevant exploration of Vladimir Putin's presidency and modern Russia, offering a disturbing yet illuminating look into the country's political landscape. The book effectively covers several major incidents and high-profile cases, providing an interesting overview for those seeking to understand the challenges of dissent and power dynamics within Russia. Its ability to make readers reflect on geopolitical events and the complexities of the region is also frequently mentioned as a strong point.
Negatives Despite its strengths, several reviewers expressed reservations about the book's depth and academic rigor. A common criticism is that much of the information presented felt speculative, with some arguing that the author attributes various crimes directly to Putin without offering tangible proof beyond insinuation, often relying on information readily available in public sources. Some critics felt the book lacked profound investigative journalism or fresh insights, suggesting it didn't go far enough beyond newspaper reports. Other points of contention include the author's perceived one-sided perspective, a lack of attention to the historical context of the Yeltsin years, and instances where the author's personal impressions seemed to influence the narrative or the veracity of claims. A few also noted that the author's liberal politics occasionally surfaced, potentially detracting from objectivity.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a compelling and often disturbing read that provides a good, albeit sometimes thin, overview of troubling trends in contemporary Russia. It is particularly recommended for readers who are new to the subject of Putin's Russia or those seeking an accessible introduction to the dangers faced by critics and journalists in the country. While some found it overly speculative, its engaging style and focus on high-profile events make it a valuable read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of modern Russian politics and its impact on individuals, especially in relation to global events. It serves as an illuminating, if sometimes controversial, account that encourages reflection on the state of freedom and power in Russia.
