Rakyat kecil, Islam, dan politik

The book is highly praised for its extensive research, spanning three decades, which provides a comprehensive overview of social, political, and religious transformations. Readers appreciate how the long-term research remains pertinent, underscoring the persistence of structural issues within society. It offers valuable insights into the enduring nature of poverty among the lower classes and explores the significant, yet often ambivalent, role of Islam in national politics.

However, a notable criticism points to a lack of cohesion in the book's structure. Specifically, the discussion in the first chapter, which examines the social conditions of the urban poor, is observed to lack a clear thematic link or 'red thread' with subsequent chapters, particularly those delving into political Islamic movements.

Overall, the book offers a deeply researched perspective on societal changes and persistent challenges, making it a valuable resource for those interested in long-term analyses of social, political, and religious dynamics. Despite some structural issues regarding chapter coherence, its strength lies in its extensive data and the relevance of its findings. It would appeal to readers seeking a comprehensive, research-driven examination of structural societal problems, particularly concerning poverty and the evolving role of religion in politics over several decades.