Rijstpap, tulpen & jihad

The book is commended for its ambitious and timely concept, aiming to explore the intricate and often misunderstood relationships between the Low Countries and the Arab and Turkish worlds over a thousand years. Reviewers appreciate the author's effort to highlight mutual influences across various domains, including language, science, and culture, presenting numerous enjoyable anecdotes and interesting facts. It offers a broad overview of Arab and Turkish contributions to Europe, spanning from intellectual fields like algebra and philosophy to cultural elements such as food and flowers. Some readers found the content full of surprises and acknowledged its ability to raise thought-provoking questions about historical connections and potential future integrations.

However, the book faces significant criticism regarding its historical accuracy and rigor. Several reviewers found factual errors upon verification, which led to serious doubts about its credibility as a historical account. The writing style is described by some as rushed and superficial, at times resembling a student's work under deadline pressure, making it difficult to discern a clear narrative amidst a dry enumeration of facts. Concerns were also raised about the author Catherine's perceived ideological bias, particularly a mild stance towards Arab and Ottoman imperialism juxtaposed with a more critical view of Western imperialism. This perceived "ideological zeal" is noted by some to undermine the book's objectivity, leading to the conclusion that it does not qualify as proper history.

Ultimately, while the book tackles a vital and under-discussed subject with a fascinating premise and intriguing arguments, its execution elicits mixed reactions. Its strengths lie in its accessible overview, interesting anecdotes, and stimulating perspectives on historical and contemporary geopolitical questions. However, these are counterbalanced by significant criticisms concerning factual inaccuracies, a perceived ideological slant, and a sometimes dry or superficial presentation. This book would primarily appeal to readers interested in a broad, accessible, and often provocative introduction to the historical interactions between the Low Countries and the Islamic world, who are prepared to approach the content with a critical eye. It is best suited for those seeking engaging insights and a particular viewpoint, rather than a meticulously researched academic history.