S'appartenir(E) gathers the voices of eight authors in a collection that explores the profound and often complex nature of self-belonging. This work delves into what it means to exist as both modern and primal, examining our relationship with education, the intricate question of one's country, and the numerous paradoxes that define contemporary life. The texts engage with history—both that which is recorded and that which remains overlooked, particularly concerning Indigenous peoples—and illuminate the subtle nuances that frequently disappear within the collective consciousness. Presented as a statement of solidarity and provocation, S'appartenir(E) invites readers to confront vital questions of identity and how individuals define themselves within a multifaceted world.
3.29
58 ratings across the web
Reviewers frequently praise the book for its powerful concept, which brings together eight women to discuss society and current events from their unique perspectives. Many highlight the beauty of the language and the strength of the message conveyed throughout the work, with some wishing they could give it more than the highest possible rating for its overall approach. Specific contributions are celebrated, and themes such as emancipation, freedom, and the idea of "belonging to oneself, in the feminine" are noted as particularly thought-provoking and resonant. Several passages are described as deeply touching and relatable, captivating readers with their insight. Despite the strong praise, some readers found the book to be inconsistent in quality, noting that certain passages were significantly better than others. A few reviewers struggled to be fully drawn into the book, with one even admitting they did not finish it. Concerns were raised about whether the book could stand on its own merit without prior knowledge of its theatrical origins. Some sections were perceived as less polished or more akin to personal venting, which created an uncomfortable reading experience for some, making them feel like they were intruding on private correspondence rather than engaging with a public work. One reviewer, while acknowledging a magnificent individual contribution, ultimately gave a very low rating, suggesting the rest of the book did not meet their expectations. Overall, the book appears to be a polarizing work, deeply appreciated for its ambitious concept and profound moments, yet criticized for its uneven execution. It seems to be an experience where the underlying idea and the themes it explores are often more impactful than every individual piece of writing. This book would likely appeal most to readers who value thought-provoking discussions on societal issues from a diverse female perspective, appreciate poetic language, and are drawn to works that explore identity, emancipation, and self-possession. It may be less suited for those seeking a uniformly polished narrative or a book that requires no external context to fully appreciate its content.

No reviews yet. Be the first.

This edition
Atelier 10, 2015
ISBN
9782924429693
Language
French

Other editions (1)