Second Lives, Second Chances

The reviews highlight the book as an engrossing, interesting, and fascinating memoir by a retired plastic and reconstructive surgeon, Donald R. Laub. Readers praised his inspiring life and dedication to making a profound difference in the world. He is lauded for pioneering international humanitarian medical missions, providing free reconstructive surgeries for conditions like cleft palates, burns, and scars to disadvantaged individuals in developing countries. Furthermore, Laub was at the forefront of gender affirmation surgery, performing hundreds of these procedures and challenging societal biases, setting an example for how faith can align with progressive medical care. Reviewers appreciated the book's direct and exact descriptions of medical operations, and his bravery, intrepidness, and honesty in detailing professional experiences were also noted as positive aspects. The inclusion of his personal journey, including a fight for life and recovery, added another captivating layer to the narrative.

Despite the praise, several reviewers pointed out drawbacks. Some found the writing style dry, too focused on the author's perspective, or characterized by a tendency to mention numerous names, which was less engaging for readers outside the medical field or the US. The detailed medical descriptions, including graphic anatomical specifics, were deemed excessive by some as the book progressed. Critics also perceived the author as having a strong personality, potentially difficult to work with, and unafraid to boast about his achievements. A significant point of contention for some was the author's documented experimentation on live animals, which was seen as lacking compassion and standing in stark contrast to his humanitarian efforts for humans. Additionally, some felt his reasoning and values rationalizations could be highly adaptable, and a few wished for more perspectives from others involved in the stories presented.

Overall, the book is considered a compelling account of an extraordinary life dedicated to improving the lives of thousands through pioneering surgical work. While some stylistic choices, a perceived self-focus, or graphic details might not appeal to every reader, the overwhelming consensus is that Dr. Laub's immense contributions to humanitarian medicine and gender affirmation surgery far outweigh these criticisms. This memoir would particularly appeal to readers interested in medical history, the evolution of plastic and reconstructive surgery, international humanitarian efforts, or the development of gender-affirming care. It is a recommended read for those seeking an inspirational story about an individual who challenged norms, dedicated his life to service, and made a significant, lasting impact on global healthcare.