Sejarah kecil Indonesia-Prancis, 1800-2000

This book is widely praised for shedding light on an often-forgotten chapter of Indonesian history, specifically the historical ties and brief presence of France in the archipelago. Many readers found it to be an interesting read, providing numerous new insights and information that challenge the common perception that only the Dutch and Japanese had significant colonial influence. For those previously unaware of France's role, the book is considered very useful and even inspiring, offering an extraordinary perspective on pre-independence relations.

However, the book also drew several criticisms. Some reviewers felt it leaned more towards a journalistic report than a rigorous historiography, with a narrative that could be boring and repetitive at times. Specific concerns were raised about the lack of in-depth analysis, particularly regarding military events, which were merely described rather than examined. Readers familiar with historical methodology also pointed out potential issues with the historical data, methods, and sources used. Additionally, the inconsistent timeline, which jumps back and forth, was found to be confusing, and the ending was perceived as abrupt or inconclusive.

In conclusion, this book serves as an accessible introduction to the historical relationship between Indonesia and France, making it highly beneficial for general readers or those with little prior knowledge of the subject. While it successfully broadens understanding of Indonesia's colonial past, readers expecting a deeply analytical or academically structured historical account might find it less satisfying. It is best suited for individuals seeking to discover new historical facts and perspectives without the expectation of a traditional scholarly work.