Sharḥ al-qawāʻid al-kullīyah: sharḥān li-qawāʻid al-Majallah

The book is highly regarded for its concise and clear explanation of general jurisprudential rules, specifically those underpinning the Majalla al-Ahkam al-Adliyyah, an Ottoman civil code based on the Hanafi school of thought. Reviewers praise its brevity and simplicity, noting that it effectively makes complex legal principles accessible. A significant advantage highlighted is its method of directly explaining these rules, which differentiates it from other similar works that often only list examples. It offers valuable insights into selected rules related to judiciary and civil transactions, serving as a useful tool for jurists to organize diverse legal issues.

However, despite its simple language, a notable criticism is the insufficient number of practical examples and applications, which can sometimes hinder a full understanding of the rules in practice. The reviewer also pointed out some specific and unusual linguistic choices made by the authors, such as particular terms used for examples and currency, which required clarification. Furthermore, even with the book's overall straightforward approach, some readers found a few of the rules challenging to grasp.

In conclusion, while the book is commendable for its succinct and direct exposition of core jurisprudential principles, its perceived simplicity does not guarantee universal accessibility. The general consensus suggests that it is primarily beneficial for specialists or those who already possess a foundational understanding of Islamic jurisprudence, particularly within the Hanafi school. For readers new to the field, the book's approach might seem unfamiliar, as it focuses on explaining rules rather than providing extensive practical illustrations. Therefore, it serves as a valuable resource for those seeking a focused and clear explanation of specific legal rules.