Shrek

Reviews for William Steig’s book "Shrek!" highlight its unique charm and groundbreaking approach to a children's story. Many readers praise the book for its original concept, presenting one of the first anti-heroes in children's literature with a protagonist who openly enjoys his repulsive nature. The illustrations, though deliberately grotesque, are frequently lauded for perfectly complementing the story's tone and being "hideously hilarious." Reviewers also appreciate the witty language, occasional poetry, and the overall entertaining quality that makes it a quick and lively read. The book’s unconventional nature, offering a "modern day fairy tale full of attitude" and a message about self-acceptance, resonated positively with many, with some even calling it a work of genius for its unhinged, childlike imagination and lack of a traditional moral.

However, a recurring point of comparison, and often a source of disappointment, is the significant difference between the book and the popular movie adaptation. Readers expecting the more benevolent movie version of Shrek found the book's protagonist to be far more explicitly ugly, mean, and actively unpleasant, making him less likable. The artwork, while fitting, was sometimes described as "juvenile" or simply "repulsive" in a way that some found unappealing. Concerns were also raised about the inclusion of certain language, such as "jackass," which some parents might find inappropriate for younger children. Several reviewers felt that the book lacked the strong character development and emotional bond with its characters that the movie achieved, making it less memorable for them.

In conclusion, "Shrek!" is seen as a seminal and highly original work, offering a twisted and unconventional take on a fairy tale. It is particularly recommended for readers who enjoy "gross" humor, stories about monsters, or the style of authors like Roald Dahl. While it provides a unique message about self-love and embracing one's true nature, prospective readers should be aware that it presents a much darker and more explicitly repulsive protagonist than the widely known film. It's a quick, entertaining read for those curious about the origin of the famous ogre and who appreciate a story that defies traditional children's book conventions.