Since We Fell

Reviews for Since We Fell highlight Dennis Lehane's strong writing, which many found to be masterful and brilliant. Readers frequently praised the protagonist, Rachel Childs, describing her as a fascinating, multi-faceted, and complex character whose struggles with panic attacks and agoraphobia were deeply explored and felt real. The book is often lauded for its compelling and absorbing nature, with many reviewers finding themselves glued to the pages, especially as the story progresses. The latter half is particularly noted for its thrilling pace, unexpected twists, and an exciting narrative that keeps readers breathless, blending a deep character study with an intriguing psychological suspense.

However, the book also drew significant criticism, primarily concerning its unconventional structure and pacing. Many reviewers felt the first half was an overlong and slow-burning backstory that didn't always connect effectively with the subsequent narrative, leading to a sense of the book having an "identity crisis." The shift from character drama to a high-stakes thriller in the second half was often perceived as jarring and implausible, stretching the suspension of disbelief for many. Some found the plot twists to be both predictable and farfetched, comparing the later chapters to a cheesy action movie. Additionally, some long-time fans of Lehane expressed disappointment, feeling the novel did not live up to the high standards set by his previous works, and noted a decline in dialogue quality towards the end.

Ultimately, Since We Fell is a divisive novel, with opinions varying widely even among the author's dedicated readership. It is a book that might appeal strongly to readers who appreciate an in-depth character study, are patient with a gradual narrative build-up, and enjoy psychological thrillers that take bold, unexpected turns, even if they occasionally strain credulity. However, those seeking a consistently fast-paced thriller from the outset or a more traditional crime narrative from Lehane might find themselves disappointed by its unique structure and dramatic shifts in tone.