Soe Hok-gie-- sekali lagi

This book is widely praised for offering fresh, humanizing perspectives on Soe Hok Gie, moving beyond his public image as a mere activist or intellectual. Reviewers particularly appreciate the personal, honest, and heartfelt contributions from his close friends, which reveal his everyday life, interactions, and even his romantic side, showcasing him as a complex individual rather than just an icon. The book is also commended for its comprehensive portrayal, including vivid accounts of his final days and rich visual documentation, such as rare photographs. Many find Gie's own historical writings, included in the collection, surprisingly relevant to contemporary issues, with his idealism and integrity continuing to serve as an inspiration. The overall presentation, including print quality, font, and layout, is also noted for enhancing the reading experience.

However, some reviewers found certain sections to be repetitive, especially those written by individuals who knew Gie only through his published works, which occasionally led to a sense of "hero worship" or overlapping information. One reviewer suggested that the book might not be ideal as an initial introduction to Gie, recommending it more as a complementary read for those already familiar with his story. While appreciating the new insights, a few readers expressed a personal preference for Gie's own words over the memoirs of others. Additionally, specific details surrounding his final journey were sometimes deemed excessively meticulous or tedious. Nevertheless, the book is also recognized for allowing for nuanced, and at times critical, perspectives on Gie's character and intellectual approach, which some reviewers found valuable for fostering a more balanced understanding.

Despite these minor criticisms, the book is overwhelmingly considered a valuable and essential addition to the existing literature on Soe Hok Gie, successfully providing a more complete and human portrayal of the figure. It is highly recommended for readers who already have some familiarity with Gie, perhaps through his previous works or the film adaptation, and wish to deepen their understanding of his multifaceted personality. The book would particularly appeal to students, activists, and anyone interested in Indonesian history, especially the student movements of the 1960s and 70s, as well as those seeking inspiration from a figure known for his integrity, courage, and idealism. Ultimately, it serves as a powerful reminder of a principled individual and his enduring relevance.