Something Rotten

Reviewers largely commend Something Rotten as a clever and engaging modern reimagining of Shakespeare's Hamlet, successfully blending classic detective noir with the original tragedy. Many found the protagonist, Horatio Wilkes, to be a witty, observant, and relatable narrator whose smart-mouthed demeanor adds humor and intrigue to the mystery. The book is lauded for its detailed characterizations and vivid settings, particularly its descriptive portrayal of the town's atmosphere. Readers appreciated the suspenseful narrative, noting that the plot picks up significantly towards the latter half, making it a compelling and hard-to-put-down read. The author's self-aware humor and ability to weave contemporary twists into the classic tale, while exploring themes of class and corporate responsibility, were also frequently highlighted as strengths that make the story fresh and appealing.

However, the book also drew criticism for several aspects. Some reviewers found Horatio's character inconsistent in the early chapters, shifting between a savvy detective and a typical teenager, and felt his extensive knowledge and outdated pop culture references strained credulity for a young adult protagonist. A recurring complaint was the slow pacing at the beginning, with some feeling that too much background information delayed the central mystery. The blend of noir, Shakespeare, and young adult elements was not always seen as cohesive, and a few readers desired a darker tone more aligned with the source material. Additionally, Horatio's commentary on female characters was occasionally described as jarring, misogynistic, or dated, and Hamilton's portrayal as a shallow, entitled friend made it difficult for some to fully invest in their bond. Other criticisms included an obvious ending and underdeveloped minor characters.

Overall, Something Rotten is generally considered a competent and enjoyable adaptation that offers a fresh perspective on a familiar story. While it has its flaws, especially concerning character consistency and initial pacing, it provides a fun and engaging reading experience for its target audience. This book is particularly recommended for young adult readers interested in mysteries or humorous stories, as well as for adults who are fans of Shakespeare's Hamlet and enjoy creative retellings. Those who appreciate a self-aware narrative voice, a blend of classic literature with modern detective tropes, and a quick-paced mystery will likely find this a worthy read.