Spells for Lost Things

The book is widely praised for its beautiful and purposeful writing, with many sentences described as meaningful and lovely. Reviewers highlight its ability to capture the best elements of the Young Adult genre, focusing on themes of youth's limitless possibilities, finding one's path, and the comfort of family, whether biological or found. The story beautifully portrays the sweetness of friendships evolving into first loves and the inherent magic of small towns. Many readers found the narrative immersive and engaging, with particular appreciation for the character of Mason, who appeals to fans of astronomy and the human connection to space. The setting of Salem, Massachusetts, is frequently lauded as atmospheric, whimsical, and a cozy autumnal backdrop that enhances the story's charm and magical elements, making it an enjoyable read for those seeking a non-scary "Halloween" or fall-themed book. The book is also commended for its mature and thoughtful exploration of deeper topics and complex family dynamics, offering a heartfelt and often emotional journey of healing, love, and resilience.

However, not all readers shared the same positive experience. A significant point of contention for some was the presence of what they perceived as "insta-love" between the main characters, which was described as cringey, cheesy, and even stalkerish in its initial depiction. Several reviewers criticized the writing style as immature, suggesting it felt more suited for middle-grade readers and resulted in a boring or painful reading experience. Character development was also a concern for some, with Willow often seen as one-dimensional, solely focused on travel and her love interest, and Mason's portrayal of trauma deemed inaccurate or unrealistic. Other supporting characters were also found to be annoying or stereotypical. Some reviewers felt the plot lacked direction or depth, describing it as a "teen melodrama" with repetitive sentiments. Additionally, aspects like the pacing were considered slow by some, and the integration of witchcraft elements was not universally enjoyed, with a few feeling it played too significant a role or that the setting's historical potential was underutilized.

Despite the divided opinions, many readers consider this a deeply emotional and memorable Young Adult novel that left them speechless and tearful. It is recommended for those who appreciate a sweet, heartwarming story that explores the journey of self-discovery, the power of found family, and overcoming personal struggles. Readers looking for an atmospheric autumnal read with subtle magical realism, set in a charming town like Salem, will likely find this book appealing. It particularly resonates with fans of character-driven narratives focused on friendship, first love, and complex family relationships, especially those who enjoy a thoughtful approach to themes of foster care and addiction. While some found it a refreshing departure or even an improvement on the author's previous works, potential readers should be aware of the differing views on pacing, character depth, and the romance's intensity to determine if it aligns with their preferences.