Spells (Unabridged Audio CDs)

Many readers found "Spells" to be an engaging continuation of the series, with some even preferring it to the first book. The world-building, particularly the detailed descriptions of Avalon and its faerie hierarchy, was frequently praised for its creativity and vivid imagery, making readers feel immersed in the magical realm. The character of Tamani garnered significant positive attention, often described as compelling and passionate, leading to strong emotional investment in his relationship with Laurel. Reviewers appreciated the heightened romantic tension and drama, especially within the central love triangle, which kept them eagerly turning pages. The book was also noted for its exciting twists and a powerful cliffhanger ending that left many desperate for the next installment. Furthermore, the narrative offered a deeper exploration of Laurel's faerie heritage and her complex relationships with both her love interests and her human family.

However, "Spells" also drew considerable criticism, with several reviewers finding the writing style to be a significant drawback, citing issues like excessive descriptions, a lack of the "show, don't tell" principle, and questionable mythological explanations. A common complaint revolved around the protagonist, Laurel, whom many perceived as indecisive, selfish, and a "crybaby" for her constant struggle with the love triangle and her fluctuating loyalty between David and Tamani. The romance with David was often described as forced or lacking chemistry, and his character sometimes deemed boring or contradictory. Reviewers felt that the plot progression was slow for much of the book, with too much time spent on explanations or repetitive scenes of Laurel's relationships, and insufficient action involving the primary antagonists. Additionally, some found the integration of various mythologies and the faerie social structure to be underdeveloped or illogical.

Ultimately, "Spells" appears to be a polarizing read, capable of eliciting strong emotional responses from its audience. While some found it to be a disappointing installment due to perceived flaws in writing, character development, and plot pacing, others were deeply captivated by the enchanting faerie world and the intense romantic drama. This book is likely to appeal most to readers who enjoyed the first book in the series and are heavily invested in the love triangle, particularly those rooting for Tamani. It will also resonate with those who appreciate richly described fantasy settings and character-driven narratives, even if the pacing is slower in parts. Readers seeking a fast-paced, action-heavy fantasy or a meticulously planned mythological system might find it less satisfying.