Starring Michael Williams & Annette Crosbie (Theatre Collection S.)

The book is widely praised by many readers as a cute, charming, and delightful story that offers a fun and lighthearted reading experience. Reviewers often highlight its imaginative premise and Roald Dahl's characteristic wit, making it an entertaining and quick read. The unique portrayal of middle-aged love is appreciated, with some finding it a heartwarming tale about human connection. The accompanying illustrations are consistently lauded as excellent, enhancing the overall enjoyment. It is often regarded as a timeless classic, suitable for a broad age range, and an accessible introduction to Dahl's distinctive storytelling. Some also note the interesting historical context provided by the author regarding pet ownership.

Conversely, a significant portion of the reviews expresses strong reservations about the book's central premise. Many readers are troubled by the protagonist's use of deceptive methods to achieve his romantic goal, leading to concerns about the moral implications conveyed, especially for younger audiences. Critics argue that the narrative could inadvertently suggest that relationships can be built on trickery and lies. The portrayal of one character as overly naive or easily misled also draws criticism, alongside questions regarding the treatment and perceived interchangeability of the pets involved in the story. For these readers, the ethical ambiguities of the protagonist's actions overshadow any intended sweetness, prompting some parents to even modify the story when reading it aloud to their children.

Ultimately, the book elicits a notably polarized response, with some readers embracing it as a whimsical and harmless tale, while others find its underlying themes deeply problematic. It is generally recognized as a short, engaging read imbued with Roald Dahl's distinctive narrative flair. Readers who appreciate quirky humor, are open to viewing the story as a fantastical or symbolic narrative rather than a literal guide to interpersonal dynamics, and are not overly concerned with explicit moral instruction, are most likely to enjoy this book. However, those who prioritize straightforward ethical lessons in children's literature or are sensitive to themes of manipulation and character naivete may find it unsettling. The book serves as a charming, quick read that often sparks discussion, with its ultimate reception largely depending on the reader's individual perspective and interpretation of its central romantic plot.