Tarzan of the Apes Edgar Rice Burroughs Authorized Library

The reviews highlight several compelling aspects of the book, particularly the initial volumes. Readers frequently praise the unique and captivating concept of a man raised by apes, finding the character of Tarzan to embody admirable human qualities and a compelling fantasy of living at one with nature. Many describe the books as amazing, providing great escapist fun and adventure. The writing style is appreciated by some, with many readers enjoying the re-reading experience and expressing a desire to relive the wonder they felt when first encountering the series. The first three books, in particular, are highly recommended for their engaging stories and distinctive premise.

However, the collection of reviews also points out significant criticisms and drawbacks. Several readers note inconsistencies and impossibilities in the narrative, suggesting the author sometimes wrote on subjects he was unfamiliar with. The portrayal of female characters is frequently criticized as "useless" or stereotypical, and some find certain lines or depictions to be "pulp trashy." A recurring and strong negative sentiment concerns the dated nature of the books, particularly the presence of racist elements and the problematic depiction of a white man as the lord of the African jungle. Some also found the second book to be a bit slow compared to the others, and the blending of jungle adventures with invented monsters or races was not universally preferred. Typos were also noted in some editions.

Despite these acknowledged deficiencies and the dated aspects, many reviewers ultimately find the books to be a worthwhile read, often viewing them as an interesting historical document. The overall verdict suggests that the strengths of the unique concept and adventurous storytelling can outweigh the weaknesses for the right reader. This book is recommended for those who can appreciate a classic work written in a different era, who are curious about its historical context, or who seek pure escapist adventure. Readers who enjoy pondering fundamental questions about human nature outside societal constraints, and who are willing to overlook or contextualize the problematic elements of their time, are most likely to find enjoyment and wonder in these iconic stories.