Tegang bentang

The book is widely praised for its comprehensive and courageous effort to document the history of Indonesian architecture, a subject that has historically lacked thorough documentation. Reviewers highlight its success in filling a crucial knowledge gap, making it an essential resource for understanding the field from the late 1800s up to the early 2010s. Beyond mere historical facts, the book is noted for presenting the values and ideas of architects relevant to their respective eras. Its methodology is commended for utilizing unique and diverse sources, including interviews, lecture notes, and memos. Readers also appreciate that complex architectural history is presented in an accessible and easy-to-understand manner, offering significant insight and broadening perspectives. Some individual essays within the collection are particularly singled out for their strong personal viewpoints and ability to contextualize individual and group journeys within broader architectural themes.

However, some readers express concerns that the book feels outdated, suggesting that its discussions often rehash old topics rather than introducing new insights or engaging with current discourses. Critics note that the content tends to repeat past facts and focuses on the origins of Indonesian architecture without sufficiently scrutinizing the very methods used to establish those beginnings. One reviewer points out that the book’s preparation for publication several years prior to its release might contribute to its perceived lack of up-to-date discussions. Additionally, while covering a century of Indonesian architecture, the book is noted for reflecting an ongoing struggle with identity issues in the field, rather than offering new critical perspectives on this persistent challenge.

Despite these criticisms regarding its currency and critical depth, the book is generally considered a highly valuable and foundational text for the history of Indonesian architecture. It is strongly recommended for anyone seeking a comprehensive and accessible introduction to the subject, including students, international scholars, or general readers interested in understanding the timeline, key figures, and influential ideas in Indonesian architecture. This book is particularly suited for those who appreciate an overview that emphasizes the journeys of individuals and groups, presented in an easy-to-digest format, even if it does not delve into the most recent academic debates or advanced critical theory.